In the sports world, the term home field advantage can be explained as the edge, whether small or large, the host team gets by playing in its own arena in front of its own fans. In American football, the home field advantage is so powerful that the betting line is generally pushed 3 points in the direction of the home team. So if, on a neutral field, the Unicorns were favored by 2 points against the Yetis, then the Unicorns would be 5 point home favorites.
I reference the term because this week I decided to compare my own wonderful and new, but small, blog to one that is slightly more established. And when looking for a comparison, why not stack it up against the cream of the crop? How about taking a look at what kind of blog “the worldwide leader in sports” has to offer.
While ESPN plays host to a number of blogs, ranging from a look at different jerseys to a fantasy reality television league, the No. 1 sports media brand likely gets the most out of its NFL Nation blog, which covers all 32 NFL teams through mini-blog communities, each dedicated to one of the league’s eight divisions (East, North, South, West for both the AFC and NFC).
Differences
Besides subject matter, in which my blog usually takes the social media angle and NFL Nation is more comprehensive, ESPN’s blog and my blog are quite different. For starters, my prized possession of Moving the Chains has only one author while NFL Nation is home to beat reporters, spread across the country each with their own focus of a four-team division. Almost all of the beat reporters come from backgrounds in print journalism and, while I was the sports editor of my high school paper, I do not.
One other variable which the two blogs do not share is voice. Likely because of its relatively young age and informal subject matter, Moving the Chains is much more conversational in language style, whereas NFL Nation is formal and tends to read, as you’d expect, like a column in your local newspaper.
You can’t ignore ESPN’s quality of reporting (+1) and quantity of posts (+1). But maybe if I had a similar staff and a compound in Bristol, I’d put out something just as good. I’d like to think that my casual voice tends to read easier as a blog than traditional print reporting.
Score: ESPN 2, Me 1.
Credibility
Despite my recent experience in the world of social media and blogging, I don’t have nearly the amount of street cred, or online cred, as any of the countless bloggers on ESPN.
With access to players, coaches and owners and an entire stasticis and information department, ESPN can incorporate quotes and stats with the snap of a finger. When I snap my finger, no such magic occurs.
I do, however, have some credibilty in the sense that I’m a Georgetown graduate student taking a class in Social Media, so I’m likely more up-to-date in terminology and history than your average Joe.
It’s not a complete shutout, but ESPN’s resouces (+1) and long-tenured writers (+1) have the sarcastically smallest edge over my brief existence in the blogging world (+.5).
Score: ESPN 4, Me 1.5
Transparency
Following in the positive trend of blog transparency, neither the beat bloggers of NFL Nation nor myself hide our identities on our respective sites. If there’s one thing I don’t like about many brand blogs out there, it’s that they lack transparency and make no effort to identify their voices.
NFL Nation makes no attempt at masking its writers and even goes to qualify each with brief biographies and resumes. By allowing readers to get a sense of where the writers are coming from, ESPN shows that they get it; blogging is not just about reporting, it’s about a community all passionate about the same topic and interested in who is saying what.
From the beginning, I made it clear that the author of Moving the Chains was not some anonymous computer voice and I’ve tried to incorporate bits of my personality here and there. While I haven’t disclosed everything, I do want my transparency to come through as I think it’s vital to any successful blog.
Even in the often personal category of transparency, ESPN discloses plenty about its bloggers (+1), making sure that readers know who is behind the curtain and even how to get in touch with them. Not wanting to be outdone, Moving the Chains also makes its author known and available for contact (+1).
Score: ESPN 5, Me 2.5
Engagement
It all comes down to this. In NFL Nation, ESPN utilizes its web power and taps into its vast community by playing host to serious community conversation. Under each blog post is a ‘Comments’ section, which usually gets pretty popular thanks to the thousands of passionate fans rooting for each of the NFL’s teams. NFL Nation also incorporates a chat component which allows readers to submit questions to ESPN’s writers, illustrating the blog’s strong two-way communication model.
In just an hour's time, this post accrued more than 200 comments.
At Moving the Chains, occasional comments appear after posts, though there is no strength in numbers like over at ESPN. In my post on Penn State’s Sandusky “situation”, I utilized a reader poll, but received less-than-stellar numbers, probably due to my lack of blog publicizing.
As it has been throughout the comparison, ESPN is able to utilize its powerful fan base in order to demonstrate its ability to communicate to readers (+1). Moving the Chains doesn’t go down without a fight, however, as the comments section is active (+1). I could, and should, do a better job though of responding to comments i(-.5) in order to replicate ESPN’s successful model.
Final Score: ESPN 6, Me 3
All in all, I highly recommend ESPN’s NFL Nation blog. It is comprehensive, full of fan conversation and probably the most credible source for NFL news. But, if you want weekly updates on the intersecting world of sports and (sometimes) social media, there is still no better Georgetown student-managed blog created for MPPR850 than Moving the Chains.
Speaking of the NFL and social media, check out this little fan-compiled video that shows the progression of social media in the world of sports.